HE vs Traditional Washers
Sat May 31 2025
- Washer Help Center
HE vs Traditional Washers: What’s the Difference?
Q: What’s the difference between an HE washer and a traditional agitator washer — and which one should I buy?
A: HE (high-efficiency) washers and traditional agitator washers clean laundry using very different methods. Each type has advantages depending on your cleaning needs, laundry habits, and water usage. Understanding the differences helps you choose the best washer for your home.
Here’s a clear comparison — explained by Beacon’s friendly technicians in the yellow polo shirt.
See all topics in the Washer Help Center.
HE Washers (High-Efficiency)
HE washers use low-water wash systems and rely on tumbling instead of a center agitator. They are available in both top-load and front-load designs.
How HE Washers Clean
Instead of a tall agitator, HE washers use:
- A low-profile wash plate (top-load HE)
- A rotating drum (front-load HE)
- High-speed spin cycles to remove more water
This approach is generally gentler on fabrics and can reduce water and energy use.
Pros of HE Washers
- Use far less water
- Gentler on clothing
- Often quieter
- Extract more water = shorter drying times
- Usually larger capacity
- More cycle options (bedding, sanitize, quick wash, etc.)
Cons of HE Washers
- Longer wash cycles are common
- Require HE detergent
- More sensitive to unbalanced loads
- Can develop odors/mildew if not maintained
Traditional Agitator Washers
Traditional washers use a tall agitator in the center of the tub to move clothes through a higher water level. The agitation is more direct and aggressive than HE tumbling.
How Agitator Washers Clean
They typically fill with more water and use the agitator to scrub and circulate clothing through the wash.
Pros of Agitator Washers
- Shorter wash cycles on many models
- Simple, proven design
- Strong mechanical action for heavy soils
- Fewer odor issues in many households
- Good for frequent laundry and work clothes
Cons of Agitator Washers
- Use significantly more water
- Can be rougher on fabrics over time
- Often smaller usable capacity (agitator takes up tub space)
- Less energy efficient overall
Which Washer Style Is Best for You?
The best washer depends on how you do laundry — and what you wash most often.
Consider an HE washer if:
- You want to save water and reduce utility costs
- You prefer gentler fabric care
- You like advanced cycles or smart features
- You regularly wash bulky items (comforters, large towels)
Consider a traditional agitator washer if:
- You want shorter, simpler wash cycles
- You wash heavily soiled clothing regularly (workwear, yard clothes)
- You prefer straightforward controls and fewer “special settings”
- Higher water use is not a concern for you
HE Washer vs Traditional Washer: Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | HE Washer | Agitator Washer |
|---|---|---|
| Water Usage | Low | High |
| Cycle Time | Usually longer | Usually shorter |
| Fabric Care | Gentle | More aggressive |
| Noise | Lower | Higher |
| Capacity | Usually larger | Usually smaller usable space |
| Detergent | HE detergent required | Standard detergent (per label) |
| Best For | Efficiency + fabric care | Heavy soils + simple operation |
Where Beacon Can Help
Both washer types can develop issues over time: vibration, draining problems, no spin, no fill, and more.
If your washer isn’t performing the way it should, our friendly technicians in the yellow polo shirt can diagnose problems such as:
- Agitator or wash plate failures
- Motor, belt, or clutch issues
- Drain pump blockages
- Sensor, lid lock, or control board problems
More washer articles:
Content Update & Editorial Review
This article was reviewed and updated on January 14, 2026 by Chris to improve clarity, expand comparisons, and add additional FAQs.
FAQ
Do HE washers get clothes as clean as agitator washers?
A: Yes, when used correctly. HE washers rely on longer wash action, proper load sizing, and HE detergent. For heavy soils, using the right cycle (Heavy Duty), warm water when appropriate, and not overloading makes a big difference.
Why do HE washers take so much longer?
A: HE washers use less water and depend on tumbling plus time to lift soils out of fabrics. Many models also add soak time, load sensing, and extra rinses automatically, which increases total runtime.
Do I really have to use HE detergent in an HE washer?
A: Yes. HE detergent is low-sudsing and designed for low-water wash systems. Too many suds can cause poor rinsing, odors, and even error codes on some models.
Why do some HE washers smell bad?
A: Low-water washing can leave behind soap residue if the washer is overloaded or too much detergent is used. Keeping the door/lid open between loads, using the correct detergent amount, and running a monthly cleaning cycle helps prevent odors.
Which washer is better for pet hair?
A: Either can work, but results depend on cycle choice and load type. HE washers often do well with bedding cycles and higher spin, while agitator washers can be strong on heavily soiled pet blankets. For stubborn pet hair, proper drying and lint management also matter.
What if my washer shakes or walks during spin?
A: This is usually caused by an unbalanced load or the washer not being level. HE top-loaders can be especially sensitive. If leveling and load adjustments don’t help, there may be suspension, bearing, or drive issues that need service.
📍 Contact Beacon Services & Appliances
📞 (352) 726-7530
🌐 www.BeaconSaves.com
Related Articles